The Grand Illusion
By
James M. Carrillo
Sr. Broker, SATC
Aug 7, 2009
Perplexed about the markets
today? How can stocks sustain a rally? Wasn’t this supposed to be the
end of the world? Did Obama save us? Is the Fed a magician? What gives?
Referring back to my article in January the markets
are playing out almost exactly as expected -- "the battle between the
bulls and bears rages on." However, we are nearing a major crux.
As mentioned in (The Lag Between Cause and Effect) I use both technical and
fundamental analysis to make decisions on where I put my money. Stock
Market fundamentals are horrid, but short-term technical data was
drastically oversold on the panic that occurred at the end of 2008 and
early 2009. However today we are at a level of needing to make serious
long-term choices.
Our banks received massive federal aid to increase lending, but
instead have been using most of that money to invest, reduce their debt and
become real estate investors. According to Realty Track there is some 600,000 homes missing from the
market. It appears they are holding homes in their own portfolios to give
the illusion of a shorter supply. This may backfire if sales don’t
reverse dramatically because a massive number of ALT A loan resets that are
now underway through 2011. This is not good for real estate prices over the
next 12 months.
Retail Sales Are
Horrendous
In the last two years, investors keep hearing the words
“bubble” and “crisis” to the point that they have
become cliché. They are thrown around far too often. But investors
should take a look at “the bigger real estate bubble” -
commercial real estate, as I warned about in January. Commercial real
estate’s decline is a very real issue facing the economy because it
may result in more losses for the financial industry than we witnessed in
residential real estate. Commercial Real Estate includes shopping malls,
apartments, hotels and office buildings.
Insurance companies among others are going to be impacted greatly
by the commercial real estate situation. Most leading insurance companies
have invested in excess of 10% of their assets into commercial mortgages.
As the value of commercial properties decline, the write-downs of these
mortgage loans on the books of these companies will severely impact their
shareholders and their customers. According to a recent article at Marketwatch: “Commercial
real estate new Achilles heel for banks” from the President of the
San Francisco Federal Reserve Branch also supports this.
Unemployment is still
increasing
Unemployment is still rising beyond the Obama forecast of 8% and there
are no new jobs to replace the ones being lost. In the twenty most populous
states, unemployed people outnumber advertised vacancies and range from a
low of roughly 2 to 1 in Maryland to about 10 to 1 in Michigan.
Next is the basic supply and demand rate of jobs, in May (latest
month unemployment numbers are available) was at 4.32, down slightly from
4.40 in April indicating that there are more than 4 unemployed workers for
every online advertised vacancy. Among the states Michigan is at 9.95, or
nearly 10 unemployed people for every advertised vacancy. Other states
where there are over 6 unemployed for every advertised vacancy include
Indiana 7.73, Kentucky 7.33, Ohio 6.54, North Carolina 6.49, and
Mississippi 6.30.
Coupled with the Commercial Real Estate issues
this does not bode well for growth.
Market
reaction
So how is the stock market rallying? First, speculation, second and
most importantly is that banks are buying stocks with bailout money. This
is really taxpayer money. Companies cut staff initially so profits do
improve in the initial quarter(s). Banks are not lending the money to
businesses and homebuyers, they are still contracting credit.
Ask yourself this, if the economy is turning around why are banks not
lending this money to the people? They see risk, which is exactly the way
we should see it. This rally is nearing technical resistance. The realities
of joblessness, lower growth revenues and a slower U.S. economy will soon
surface.
Remember, if the majority of companies, corporations and governments
are cutting 10-20% of their employees for the sake of making the books look
better with no new jobs to replace them, who will be buying the products
over the coming months and years? Answer: Very few. The expectations of GDP
growth are fantasy when 72 percent of GDP is consumption.
China and inflation
The biggest problem I see is that China is booming. Yes, I said
problem. I liken the infrastructure build outs in China and India to that
of a locust infestation on all raw goods and materials. The recent report
of China having a $2 trillion-dollar surplus is alarming and should make us
all shudder. They act like our friend and allies but are they really?
Unlike the US, China has a $2 trillion surplus to invest with
relatively few obstacles towards long-term growth. China has wisely begun
to diversify away from investing in foreign treasury securities by building
on its emerging market plan expected to hit 7.2% GDP growth (The World
Bank). It has been aggressively pursuing major acquisitions and investments
in gold, oil, copper and coal commodity companies and other investments.
China has recently strengthened relations with Russia while both agreed
to oppose trade protectionism. It has promised to support Russia's bid for
membership of the World Trade Organization (WTO). China mainly exports
machinery, light industrial products and textiles to Russia. Russia's
exports of natural resources to China primarily include crude oil, natural
gas and lumber.
Why is this a problem?
The Chinese population is 1,330,044,544; India’s is
1,147,995,904. The United States has 304,059,724 as of 2008. You should now
understand what I meant by saying “a locust infestation on all raw
goods and materials”.
The problem here is simple to understand. We have printed over a
trillion dollars of currency backed by nothing but the full faith and
credit of the United States government. The U.S is a debtor nation and we
are now competing with mass surplus countries. Basic economics insists that
this could rapidly erode our dollar’s buying power as the currency
loses value. Either way you look at it those dollars will buy less over
time because there is a lag between cause and effect that must not be
ignored.
Couple our dollar dilution/devaluation with the fact we are now
competing with these growing mega-countries for raw materials that are
already in short supply. They have a combined populace that is seven times
larger than ours. Perhaps now you better understand why I liken
Chindia’s size and growth to a locust infestation.
Beware of the Chinese banking and stock bubble. China is also creating
its own banking bubble by printing Yuan like crazy, growing their money
supply by 100’s of percent. There is a serious disparity in growth of
money vs. their economic build out. This all could easily fail especially
since they hold massive amounts of U.S. Treasury debt. The Yuan will not be
a solution to the world’s problems. This may ultimately lead to a one
world currency.
The Treasury auctions held this last week of July tell a story far more
disturbing than what we hear. The $39 billion auction of five-year notes
(the largest such sale ever) wasn't bid heavily enough to prevent the
Treasury from paying a higher rate on its borrowing habits.
Rising yields not only affect our government's borrowing costs, thus
increasing the deficit, but also increase costs of borrowing to consumers
and businesses, since the 10-year note is the most commonly used pricing
benchmark for mortgages and corporate borrowing.
The international ratings agency, Standard and Poor's, has recently
changed its outlook for the British economy from stable to negative because
of soaring government debt.
Sound familiar?
The ratings watchers have also cast a huge shadow on the struggling US
economy after a top investor warned America's AAA rating was in jeopardy as
well.
Moody's Investors Service downgraded California's general-obligation
bond rating to Baa1 from A2 this month. It was the second two-notch
downgrade this month after Fitch Ratings issued an identical drop recently.
California is the largest economy in the U.S. and would be the eighth
largest economy in the world if it were a country.
Derivatives Disaster
Simplified, the term "derivative" refers to a
"derived" wager, or bet, on the price of something. If you
don’t completely understand these bets don’t feel alone, even
the Fed Chairman, Warren Buffet, Bill Gates and the brightest financial
minds in the world don’t fully understand derivatives, but this graph
will give you an idea of the sheer size of this market.
Yes those are TRILLIONS. Why should we
care?
"Derivatives are financial weapons of mass destruction," said
Warren Buffet back in 2003. He knew it then and they have grown massively
since then to over $600 trillion.
Buffet's concern becomes clear when you see what this total equates to.
The dollar is the world's reserve currency, so the majority of all
derivatives are transacted in U.S. dollars. These are trillions of dollars
of worthless fiat transactions that dwarf the rest of the world. By
comparison our debt, dollars and GDP figures seem small;
* $9 Trillion Total Monetary Supply of US
Dollars, cash, coin, and banking accounts.
* $15 Trillion Total 2008 GDP, or the market value of all goods and
services the U.S.
* $50 Trillion Total
world GDP in 2008, per US Global
* $75
Trillion Total value of the world's real estate, per US Global
* $77 Trillion Total nominal value of world's ETD
derivatives, per BIS
* $100 Trillion Total
value of the world's stock AND bond markets, per US Global
* $684 Trillion Total nominal value of world's OTC derivatives, per
BIS
The fact that we are only now trying to regulate this mess and curb
trading may very well cause the collapse of this market. Now you understand
why I say, “I currently do not trust paper assets in any form.”
Updated projections
The S&P 500
Technically, we most likely will rally over 1000 on the S&P500
upwards of 1080, but as stated earlier I choose to widely ignore this rally
because it has zero fundamental support. It could turn rapidly and wipe out
fortunes overnight. If you are still in the market you are most likely
looking a gift horse in the mouth in my opinion. Look for a great selling
opportunity above 9500 on the Dow and 1000-1050 on the S&P 500.
Nothing has changed fundamentally. The idea of flooding the
markets with massive amounts of new currency will either work and we will
come out of it in a massive inflationary spiral because, too much money
chases to few goods and services, or it won’t work at all. Pray for
the former. I don’t believe any middle ground exists.
The U.S. Dollar
The US Dollar is nearing a break point now. July’s monthly close
below .7900 was a major sell signal to worldwide fund managers. It is
currently trading dangerously close in that .7900 area. Fundamentals are in
place for a free fall, lower employment, banking problems, real estate
glut, major issues within the commercial sector with poor auctions, forcing
the Fed to buy back its own debt. This is like using your Mastercard to pay
the Visa bill.
However technically, we haven’t received the next U.S.
dollar sell signal just yet. Fundamentally you can’t sell me on the
idea that we can mass-produce world currency and U.S. dollars and make them
worth more. The more there is, the less they are worth. Again, basic
economics dictates this is going to be a long-term inflation spiral created
by monetary inflation, it will require more dollars to buy the same goods
and services regardless of what the talking heads want us to believe.
GOLD
Gold has done what I hoped for last January as the best case scenario,
I quote “If we are lucky we will get a choppy sideways pattern until
August with a moon shot move up into 2010.” My conviction continues
to be that, “it is better to be a year too early than five minutes
too late. Accumulate gold now before the dollar falls into the
abyss.”
Gold is the anti-dollar because it moves in the exact opposite
“a mirror image” to the value of the dollar. Buy the dips if we
get any. The longer gold moves sideways the larger the move will be.
CONCLUSION
Looking at the above charts, I ask you: which market is stronger? Where
would you have rather been over the past decade? What has changed? The
world melted down in 2008 and early 2009. Gold stands firm and massive
amounts of currency are being printed worldwide. Fundamentally nothing has
changed and technically the long-term trend of stocks remains down, the
dollar has re-established and triggered a new down trend, gold once again
appears to be the major benefactor. The talking heads tell us one thing,
but common sense, the numbers and the overall trends tell us that the
stock, bond and real estate market rallies are nothing but a grand
illusion. Remember, the best way to dump dollars is to buy gold.